FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   ANALYZE DATA: Help with R | SPSS | Stata | Excel   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | Int'l Relations | Law & Courts
   FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | IR | Law & Courts
If this link is broken, please report as broken. You can also submit updates (will be reviewed).
Insights from the Field

Female Math Teachers Raise Math Confidence in Boys and Girls


representative bureaucracy
gender congruence
self-concept
stereotypes
survey experiment
Teaching and Learning
JBPA
1 Stata files
1 Datasets
Dataverse
The Individual Level Effect of Symbolic Representation: An Experimental Study on Teacher-student Gender Congruence and Students' Perceived Abilities in Math. was authored by Laura Doornkamp, Petra Van den Bekerom and Sandra Groeneveld. It was published by JPBA in JBPA in 2019.

📌 What Was Tested

This study investigates how passive gender representation — when a teacher's gender matches a student's — affects students' academic self-concepts in math. Theoretical ideas from representative bureaucracy are combined with insights from social and educational psychology to build a model that explains individual-level mechanisms linking gender congruence to student outcomes.

🔎 How the Study Was Conducted

  • A survey experiment administered to high school students in the Netherlands.
  • The core hypothesis: gender congruence between teacher and student increases students' academic self-concept in math.
  • Proposed mechanism: this positive effect is mediated by students' gender-stereotypical beliefs and is moderated by the teacher's self-confidence.

📈 What Was Found

  • The predicted mediated relationship (gender congruence → stereotypical beliefs → academic self-concept), with moderation by teacher self-confidence, was not supported by the experimental data.
  • Clear gender differences exist in both stereotypical beliefs and academic self-concepts among students.
  • Notably, students' math self-concept — for both male and female students — is higher when the math teacher is a woman.

💡 Why It Matters

  • Results challenge simple mechanism assumptions about how passive representation operates at the individual level, showing that expected pathways via stereotypical beliefs and teacher self-confidence did not explain effects in this setting.
  • The observed link between female math teachers and higher student math self-concept suggests meaningful representational effects that merit further investigation.
  • The study concludes with recommendations for future research to unpack when and how stereotypical beliefs shape the relationship between gender representation and student performance.
data
Find on Google Scholar
Find on JSTOR
JPBA
JBPA
Podcast host Ryan