FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   ANALYZE DATA: Help with R | SPSS | Stata | Excel   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | Int'l Relations | Law & Courts
   FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | IR | Law & Courts
If this link is broken, please report as broken. You can also submit updates (will be reviewed).
Insights from the Field

Insiders don't always oppose outsiders: Skill level shapes redistribution preferences


insiders
outsiders
skill level
survey experiment
Latin America
Latin American Politics
CPS
3 R files
3 Stata files
3 datasets
1 text files
Dataverse
Insiders, Outsiders, Skills and Preferences for Social Protection: Evidence from a Survey Experiment in Argentina was authored by Irene Menendez Gonzalez. It was published by Sage in CPS in 2021.

Comparative political economy theory suggests labor market insiders typically resist redistribution for outsiders, but this isn't universally true.

New Insight Needed:

Economic insecurity actually leads to greater polarization in social policy preferences between low- and high-skilled workers. This groundbreaking finding reveals that insider perspectives vary significantly based on skill level.

### Experiment Details & Findings ###

* Methodology: A survey experiment with a nationally representative sample of Argentinians, complemented by observational data from 16 Latin American countries (2015-2020).

* The experiment randomly exposed participants to scenarios highlighting job risk.

* Key Results:

* Low-skilled workers primed with outsider risk become significantly more supportive of social transfers

* High-skilled workers primed with insider threat show stronger preference for protecting their own status quo position

* Polarization is evident across skill levels when economic insecurity perceptions are heightened.

* Policy Significance:

* This research provides crucial micro-level foundations for understanding political dynamics around social policy in middle-income democracies.

* It suggests targeted approaches to reducing polarization could reshape political coalitions supporting social protection expansion.

### Scholarly Context ###

This study extends existing work on insider-outsider dynamics by demonstrating how economic security perceptions mediate preferences for redistribution. The findings offer a nuanced perspective essential for analyzing contemporary redistributive politics in developing economies.

data
Find on Google Scholar
Find on JSTOR
Find on Sage Journals
Comparative Political Studies
Podcast host Ryan