FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   ANALYZE DATA: Help with R | SPSS | Stata | Excel   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | Int'l Relations | Law & Courts
   FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | IR | Law & Courts
If this link is broken, please report as broken. You can also submit updates (will be reviewed).
Valid Warnings About Fake News Backfire: Discarding Truth to Avoid Falsehood
Insights from the Field
misinformation warnings
tainted truth effect
political memory
Political Behavior
Pol. Behav.
1 R files
1 Stata files
10 other files
2 datasets
1 text files
Dataverse
Fake Claims of Fake News: Political Misinformation, Warnings, and the Tainted Truth Effect was authored by Melanie Freeze, Mary Baumgartner, Peter Bruno, Jacob R. Gunderson, Joshua Olin, Justine Szafran and Morgan Quinn Ross. It was published by Springer in Pol. Behav. in 2021.

Fact-checking and misinformation warnings are common in modern political discourse. This research examines how these interventions impact information processing.

Data & Methods

Drawing from studies in social cognition, we analyze the effects of both accurate and inaccurate news labels on credibility perceptions and memory retention.

Key Findings

• Accurate retro-warnings about misleading content often fail to effectively persuade readers due to weak correction impact

• False warnings taint legitimate information, leading individuals to discard authentic political knowledge

• The "tainted truth effect" demonstrates how suspicion of misinformation can paradoxically cause rejection of factual reports

Why It Matters

Our findings highlight unintended consequences of widespread misinformation campaigns:

• They may inadvertently undermine the credibility of legitimate news sources

• They risk damaging citizens' ability to retain important political information over time

These results suggest policymakers and media organizations should reconsider blanket statements about fake news.

data
Find on Google Scholar
Find on JSTOR
Find on Springer
Political Behavior
Podcast host Ryan