NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials of Poltical Analysis 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | More Textbooks 🎵
If this link is broken, please
You can also
(will be reviewed).

Mainstream Politicians' Anti-Immigrant Rhetoric Erodes Tolerance More Than Radical Right

Study Significance

The paper addresses whether anti-immigrant rhetoric changes public perceptions of what exclusionary speech and behavior are socially acceptable, and whether those effects depend on whether the speaker is a mainstream politician or a radical-right politician.

Measuring Norm Perceptions

Respondents were exposed to anti-immigrant statements attributed to different kinds of politicians and afterward reported their perceptions of social norms around tolerance, which the authors use as the outcome measure.

Comparison of Statement Senders

The experiment compared reactions to similar anti-immigrant remarks when they were attributed either to mainstream-right politicians or to radical-right politicians, and it examined heterogeneity by respondents' ideological leaning.

Main Experimental Findings

Statements by mainstream politicians produced greater erosion of tolerance norms than identical statements attributed to radical-right politicians.

Subsample analyses indicate the effect is driven by right-wing respondents: mainstream-right statements reduce right-leaning respondents' sense that tolerance is the norm, whereas radical-right statements provoke a backlash among left-wing respondents who hold more strongly to tolerant norms in response.

Authors' Interpretation

The authors argue the difference occurs because mainstream politicians represent a larger part of the population or possess higher status, which makes their exclusionary statements more effective at changing perceived norms.

British Journal of Political Science
How Mainstream Politicians Erode Norms was authored by Vicente Valentim, Elias Dinas and Daniel Ziblatt. It was published in BJPS in 2025. Find on Google Scholar10.1017/S0007123425100586
Comparative Politics subfield banner