This paper asks whether federal research-and-development (R&D) grants change how U.S. states allocate their own R&D funds, comparing effects on university-based research versus R&D performed by state government agencies. The central contribution is an empirical comparison showing a null relationship for state academic allocations and a positive, partial dollar-for-dollar response in state agency R&D, with computational text analysis used to probe why the effects differ.
Primary comparison of university vs. state-agency R&D Estimated $0.35 state agency response per federal dollar Use of computational text analysis to assess award localization
Data and methods
The authors study federal R&D grants and state R&D spending in the United States over 2006–2021, estimating how additional federal support relates to state allocations. The abstract reports separate empirical estimates for academic R&D and for R&D performed by state government agencies, and it notes the use of computational text analysis on recent federal awards to assess differences in the localization of benefits.
Main findings
The abstract summarizes two contrasting results: federal grants to academic R&D are not associated with significant changes in state allocations to academic institutions, while R&D carried out by state government agencies is estimated to rise by $0.35 for each additional federal dollar. The authors argue the divergence likely reflects more localized benefits from state-agency R&D compared to university-based research, and say their computational text analysis corroborates this hypothesis.
- No significant effect on state allocations to academic institutions, 2006–2021.
- Positive association for state government agency R&D: roughly $0.35 increase per federal dollar.
