NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials of Poltical Analysis 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | More Textbooks 🎵
If this link is broken, please
You can also
(will be reviewed).

Why Mayors Still Stall Women's Rise Even Under Proportional Representation

📚 A century of Norwegian candidate records

Proportional representation (PR) systems—especially closed-list PR—tend to have a higher share of women in politics than majoritarian systems, yet progress toward gender parity has been slow and uneven. This study examines whether single-occupant offices that function as career stepping stones create hidden majoritarian barriers to women's advancement.

🔎 What was traced and tested

  • Focus on single-occupant “majoritarian stepping stones,” such as local mayor and list leader positions.
  • Two research questions: 1) Do gender gaps emerge at these stepping-stone posts? 2) How does access to these posts affect women’s progression into higher offices?
  • A century of detailed candidate-level data from Norway is used to trace career trajectories and compare promotion patterns by gender.

📈 Key findings from the empirical analysis

  • Gender gaps do emerge at majoritarian stepping stones: women are underrepresented in single-occupant local posts that serve as common routes to higher office.
  • Parties have adopted compensating practices: when women occupy these stepping-stone positions they are often promoted to higher office at higher rates than men, reducing the negative effect of the initial gap.
  • These party-level workarounds mitigate—but do not fully erase—the adverse impact of hidden majoritarianism on women’s overall representation in higher offices.

💡 Why this matters

  • Even in PR systems that appear more gender-inclusive, single-seat offices can create bottlenecks that slow women's career progression.
  • The findings highlight the importance of looking beyond electoral systems to intra-party promotion practices and career pathways when assessing obstacles to gender parity.
American Political Science Review
Hidden Majoritarianism and Women's Career Progression in Proportional Representation Systems was authored by Daniel M. Smith, Alexandra Cirone, Dawn L. Teele, Gary W. Cox and Jon H. Fiva. It was published in APSR in 2026. Find on Google Scholar10.1017/S0003055425100786
Comparative Politics subfield banner