FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   ANALYZE DATA: Help with R | SPSS | Stata | Excel   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | Int'l Relations | Law & Courts
   FIND DATA: By Author | Journal | Sites   WHAT'S NEW? US Politics | IR | Law & Courts
If this link is broken, please report as broken. You can also submit updates (will be reviewed).
Beyond Assumptions: New Paths to Causal Understanding
Insights from the Field
causal mechanism
minimum assumption
estimation algorithm
sensitivity analysis
Methodology
APSR
1 archives
Dataverse
Unpacking the Black Box of Causality: Learning About Causal Mechanisms from Experimental and Observational Studies was authored by Kosuke Imai, Luke Keele, Dustin Tingley and Teppei Yamamoto. It was published by Cambridge in APSR in 2011.

This paper tackles a central challenge in political science research: studying causal mechanisms more effectively. It identifies the limitations of common statistical approaches – they often rely on untestable assumptions and don't capture how effects unfold.

🔑 New Approach Needed

Authors highlight that simply randomizing variables isn't enough, making it crucial to improve this vital area without abandoning its importance.

🛠️ Three Key Contributions

  • 📌 Minimum Assumptions: Defines the essential criteria for standard experimental and observational designs.
  • 💡 General Estimation Algorithm: Develops a method for calculating causal mediation effects based on these minimum requirements.
  • 🔍 Sensitivity Assessment: Provides tools to evaluate how conclusions hold up if key assumptions might be violated.

🧩 Alternative Designs

The paper also offers weaker-assumption approaches for identifying mechanisms.

📊 Illustration with Examples

These concepts are demonstrated using real-world cases like media framing experiments and incumbency advantage studies.

data
Find on Google Scholar
Find on JSTOR
Find on CUP
American Political Science Review
Podcast host Ryan