NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials of Poltical Analysis 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | R Companion 4e | SPSS 7e | Stata 5e | Excel 1e 🎵
NOW AVAILABLE: Essentials 7e | More Textbooks 🎵
If this link is broken, please
You can also
(will be reviewed).

Proportional Representation's Hidden Bias: Why District Size Matters for Voter Equality

Problem Statement

In proportional representation (PR) systems with districts, voters across different district types experience varying levels of representational equality.

New Data Measure

This study introduces a new conceptual framework and measure to evaluate electoral inequality within PR systems that use mixed district structures.

Findings

Districted PR often results in right-leaning parties being overrepresented among voters who reside in semi-majoritarian districts.

Across all Western parliamentary democracies, larger district magnitudes (the number of MPs per constituency) are associated with reduced representational inequality.

Significance

These findings challenge the assumption that PR inherently guarantees equal representation for all citizens across different voting districts.

American Journal of Political Science
Are Voters Equal Under Proportional Representation? was authored by Orit Kedar, Liran Harsgor and Raz A. Sheinerman. It was published in AJPS in 2016. Find on Google Scholar10.1111/ajps.12225
Comparative Politics subfield banner